1094 Followers
220 Following
SusannaG

SusannaG - Confessions of a Crazy Cat Lady

Just another GR refugee.  Other than that, I had a stroke in 2004, and read almost anything I can get my hands on, though I have a particular weakness for history, mystery, and historical fiction.

Currently reading

Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind
Yuval Noah Harari Dr
Progress: 5 %
Lady Cop Makes Trouble
Amy Stewart
The Invention of Nature: Alexander von Humboldt's New World
Andrea Wulf
Progress: 2 %
The Hundred Years War, Volume 1: Trial by Battle
Jonathan Sumption
Progress: 166/586 pages
King Solomon's Mines
H. Rider Haggard
Progress: 4 %
Queen's Gambit: A Novel
Elizabeth Fremantle
Progress: 22 %
1913: The Eve of War
Paul Ham
Progress: 20 %
The William Shakespeare Detective Agency: The Dark Lady (The William Shakespeare Detective Agency Book 2)
Colin Falconer
Progress: 15 %
Cosmic Quest Cd (Bbc Audio)
Heather Couper
Firedrake's Eye
Patricia Finney
Progress: 15/249 pages

Terry Jones' Medieval Lives

Terry Jones' Medieval Lives - Alan Ereira, Terry Jones

Terry Jones (yes, that one - before he was a Python he read medieval history at Cambridge) does a good job in his Medieval Lives of painting how the medieval period isn't one huge monolith of culture and situation.  That it's a lot more than endlessly toiling peasants, knights in shining armor, and damsels in distress.  (Most of the damsels he discusses seem to have rescued themselves, actually.)

 

I was tempted to lower the rating to 3.5 stars, however, on the basis of the last chapter, "King," where he discusses how medieval kings are "the good, the bad, and the ugly," but not necessarily the ones that we think of.  He looks mostly at England's three Richards.

 

I agree with his assessment of Richard I - not nearly as fair as his medieval propaganda paints him.

 

On the other hand, his attempted "John: not so bad" rewrite I don't give a pass to.  If you are a medieval monarch and:

 

A. your barons rise up and make the kingdom ungovernable, and force you to terms

B. the Pope invites the neighboring king to invade you because you're annoying him so much

C. the king of France takes him up on the offer

D. you try to get around C. by giving your kingdom to the Pope

and

E. you are succeeded by a regency for a nine-year-old (a complete disaster in most medieval cases) AND IT'S AN IMPROVEMENT,

 

you might not be a great king.  John may not be a cardboard villain, and his brother Richard the shining superstar, but John still wasn't a great king.  And he spent more time in England than Richard (Richard spent only six months there, in ten years as king) largely because he couldn't hold on to most of his French holdings.

 

On Richard II and Richard III, I'll just say that the material here is so complex that it doesn't work well for this kind of format, I think.  (I'll give a pass on one outright error in the Richard III segment, because this book was written in 2004, when they hadn't found his body yet.  He did indeed have a bad case of scoliosis, and probably some sort of hunched back.)